If you try to buy or rent a home in Milan, Rome or Florence, it feels like playing a game in which the rules for you are different from those for the other participants. And the reality is that this is exactly how it is.
Soaring property prices are no longer just a question of inflation or a shortage of supply. There is an elephant in the room that gets far too little attention: the distorting impact of tax breaks for foreigners and new residents.
Introduced with the laudable aim of attracting capital, expertise and international "high rollers" (I am thinking of the Flat Tax on foreign income, which the Budget Law has progressively raised to €300,000 to curb excesses, or the previous regimes for incoming workers), these measures have ended up producing a serious side effect on Real Estate.
Here is what is happening beneath the surface:
Competitive asymmetry: Those who arrive with substantial wealth and flat-rate taxation on foreign income have spending power and financial leverage that are incomparable with those of a local professional or family, taxed at progressive personal income-tax rates (up to 43%).
Gentrification of the "Prime" segment: Demand for prestigious and luxury properties has literally skyrocketed. This has caused a cascading effect: luxury-segment prices pull the upper end upwards, which in turn pushes up the middle segment, creating an artificial bubble.
Disconnection from local wages: Prices per square metre in our metropolitan areas no longer respond to the wage dynamics of the real Italian economy; instead, they are linked to the global purchasing power of those who choose Italy as a haven for lifestyle and light taxation.
The increase in the Flat Tax (from the previous €200k) for new entrants shows that regulators, too, are beginning to recognise the overheating risk. But the question remains open.
How far is it sustainable to "artificially stimulate" property values to attract liquid capital if the price to pay is the expulsion of the middle class and young professionals from city centres?
Attracting talent and capital is essential, but the real challenge for the future will be doing so without compromising the social and housing fabric of our cities.
What do you think? Are you seeing this "disconnect" on the ground?